The Guildmasters' Dinner Logic Puzzle

silver_tigress · **Posts:** 48 **Joined:** Thu Nov 11, 2004 9:11 pm

if you know, for example, that Sabatha is allergic to steak (and therefor can't have the steak platter meal), you'd cross out the box that's the intersection of Sabatha and steak platter.

If you know that Sabatha ate the steak platter, you'd make some mark in that intersection to note that (I just circle the box)..then you can cross out anything else in that foods&names section that would contradict that fact.

By the end, all of the chart should be crossed off except for 6 boxes per section (60 boxes)...those are the answers to the puzzle.

Robert · **Posted:** Thu Nov 18, 2004 8:54 pm

silver_tigress wrote:

if you know, for example, that Sabatha is allergic to steak (and therefor can't have the steak platter meal), you'd cross out the box that's the intersection of Sabatha and steak platter.

If you know that Sabatha ate the steak platter, you'd make some mark in that intersection to note that (I just circle the box)..then you can cross out anything else in that foods&names section that would contradict that fact.

By the end, all of the chart should be crossed off except for 6 boxes per section (60 boxes)...those are the answers to the puzzle.

Alright, thats what I thought, but wasn't sure, tahnks for your help

Erin · **Posts:** 1093 **Joined:** Tue Jul 27, 2004 8:47 pm

Also (and this had me confused for awhile so I'm clarifying) if they tell us that whoever likes steak also steals plushies, we cross off the intersection between steak and plushie thief. ^^

yptee · **Posted:** Thu Nov 18, 2004 9:59 pm

I am trying to practice using the Gadgadbogen puzzle but I do not think the clues in the site is complete (there must be some hidden clues), and there is no answer as well.

Anybody know where i can find the hidden clues and answer?

Crimsonmon · **Posted:** Thu Nov 18, 2004 10:35 pm

The thing I don't get is why the charts have more than one row, I can't see the use in having each section twice...

boatingbabe2001 · **Posts:** 150 **Joined:** Sun Nov 07, 2004 5:52 pm

Crimsonmon wrote:

The thing I don't get is why the charts have more than one row, I can't see the use in having each section twice...

You need to list all but one of the sections twice so that you can cross refrence things. TNT could give you a clue that relates the name to the food, or the food to the secret. The layout that has been shown in these post allows you to relate any of the categories to any of the other ones. Without the cross refrences it would basically be impossible to solve the puzzle.

YesItIsh · **Posted:** Fri Nov 19, 2004 1:11 am

I wanna join!

AIM: zapasmack

Not one of these again.....I guess I'll print one of the spreadsheets or something...

LaceyJade · **Posts:** 571 **Joined:** Fri Nov 05, 2004 5:40 pm

My name on AIM is Sesame23.

This'll be loads of fun. Eightbitloser (Dollie as I call her) and I have already started on a 'likeliness' chart -

Malkus Vile would be most likely for gem theft as his specialty and for his secret it would be either selling faeries to Balthazar or burying 1m NP underground.

And whoever's the card shark would definitely have the Scarab 21 avatar.

Aaaand those are all I'm pretty sure on.

boatingbabe2001 · **Posts:** 150 **Joined:** Sun Nov 07, 2004 5:52 pm

LaceyJade wrote:

My name on AIM is Sesame23.

This'll be loads of fun. Eightbitloser (Dollie as I call her) and I have already started on a 'likeliness' chart -

Malkus Vile would be most likely for gem theft as his specialty and for his secret it would be either selling faeries to Balthazar or burying 1m NP underground.

And whoever's the card shark would definitely have the Scarab 21 avatar.

Aaaand those are all I'm pretty sure on.

Good theories and all but remember, this is TNT. What they do doesn't have to make sense to anyone at all.

this_is_cath · **Posts:** 73 **Joined:** Thu Nov 18, 2004 5:24 pm

im no good at plot solving..but ill try to help

Yuusuke · **Posts:** 13 **Joined:** Thu Nov 18, 2004 9:30 am

LaceyJade wrote:

My name on AIM is Sesame23.

This'll be loads of fun. Eightbitloser (Dollie as I call her) and I have already started on a 'likeliness' chart -

Malkus Vile would be most likely for gem theft as his specialty and for his secret it would be either selling faeries to Balthazar or burying 1m NP underground.

And whoever's the card shark would definitely have the Scarab 21 avatar.

Aaaand those are all I'm pretty sure on.

Basing things on 'likenesses', wouldn't it make more sense for Masila to be the gem thief, just from the appearance of her? I mean, she is wearing a lot of jewels...

AIM: Otakumon3

Erin · **Posts:** 1093 **Joined:** Tue Jul 27, 2004 8:47 pm

The First Clue Has Been Announced!

The Poison specialist had the steak platter.

Check it off on your charts!

Also, Masila has been added to the GoE, but it doesn't look like there's any information there.

Alex · **Posted:** Sat Nov 20, 2004 7:06 am

Oooh, yay!

Too bad the reward hasn't been announced yet

gemma58 · **Posted:** Sat Nov 20, 2004 7:50 am

To get people started:

Sylence · **Posts:** 1159 **Joined:** Sun Jun 13, 2004 9:40 pm

I am so wanting in on this alreayd we have haklf of one person solved with their first clue we just need to figure out down the line who ate steak or did poisons It'l;l be interesting and do add/invite me for anything as I so want in on this and have a chance to win those avatars *S*

sylencedarkheart is my aim *S*

Pink Poogle Toy Forum

The Guildmasters' Dinner Logic Puzzle

Who is online