Tue Nov 16, 2004 3:45 am
ScottNak wrote:1) Would you rather executions take place at 6 or 7 pm?
2) Aside from a few mistakes, were there any problems you saw in this game?
3) Was the game fairly balanced? Was it unfair to one side? If so... which?
4) Any other comments relating to the game itself?
1: Meh, I don't really care, but 6 would be fine.
2: Well, aside from dying in the first round, I had no problem whatsoever.
3: I don't really know. Maybe more bad guy roles?
4: Not really.
Tue Nov 16, 2004 4:11 am
Well, the execution time should be moved to 6 because that does make a big difference to the East coast people, and for the west coast it isn't too much of a difference at all. If someone on the west coast couldn't be on at 6 they would still be able to get on at the time they're getting on now so it only gives more chances to people.
I do believe it was fairly balanced because it did get pretty close in the end. Had it been more toward the bad guy's side then more innocents would've been taken out, and they would've easily lost.
I loved it, and I would be willing to give up my spot in the game to post things for you if you think you're going to be busy again so that you don't need to worry about the game.
I do believe it was fairly balanced because it did get pretty close in the end. Had it been more toward the bad guy's side then more innocents would've been taken out, and they would've easily lost.
I loved it, and I would be willing to give up my spot in the game to post things for you if you think you're going to be busy again so that you don't need to worry about the game.
Tue Nov 16, 2004 6:32 am
Question: Did the best buddies have any role?
Tue Nov 16, 2004 6:45 am
Nope. They just knew each other were 100% innocent.
Tue Nov 16, 2004 8:51 am
1) Would you rather executions take place at 6 or 7 pm?
Either, I'm at school at both times anyway.
2) Aside from a few mistakes, were there any problems you saw in this game?
Not really, no. Or there are some but I just can't think of any right now.
3) Was the game fairly balanced? Was it unfair to one side? If so... which?
Even though I'm an innocent, I do with to see more bad guys lol and maybe a change of bad guys (except for Werewolves because that that's original character?). Well...the moongazer thing, I think it just makes people groan XD
4) Any other comments relating to the game itself?
What do the best buddies do anyway?
Either, I'm at school at both times anyway.
2) Aside from a few mistakes, were there any problems you saw in this game?
Not really, no. Or there are some but I just can't think of any right now.
3) Was the game fairly balanced? Was it unfair to one side? If so... which?
Even though I'm an innocent, I do with to see more bad guys lol and maybe a change of bad guys (except for Werewolves because that that's original character?). Well...the moongazer thing, I think it just makes people groan XD
4) Any other comments relating to the game itself?
What do the best buddies do anyway?
Tue Nov 16, 2004 12:01 pm
1) Would you rather executions take place at 6 or 7 pm?
6 is earlier for me, so it's better.
2) Aside from a few mistakes, were there any problems you saw in this game?
No, not really.
3) Was the game fairly balanced? Was it unfair to one side? If so... which?
I believe it was well balanced.
4) Any other comments relating to the game itself?
This may have been answered, but is the sniper an innocent or baddie?
6 is earlier for me, so it's better.
2) Aside from a few mistakes, were there any problems you saw in this game?
No, not really.
3) Was the game fairly balanced? Was it unfair to one side? If so... which?
I believe it was well balanced.
4) Any other comments relating to the game itself?
This may have been answered, but is the sniper an innocent or baddie?
Tue Nov 16, 2004 4:08 pm
I don't have much to say... the game was good, and since I'm sleeping anyway when executions take place, 1 hour of difference isn't important for me...
Tue Nov 16, 2004 10:46 pm
1) Would you rather executions take place at 6 or 7 pm?
Hmm... 6=8; 7=9. I think I'd rather have it still be at 7, because that gives me more time since I'm usually busy during the day on weekends. But 6 would seem to help more people, so either would be fine.
2) Aside from a few mistakes, were there any problems you saw in this game?
Nope.
3) Was the game fairly balanced? Was it unfair to one side? If so... which?
I don't think so, it came really close at the end, which means, in my opinion, that both sides were pretty even.
4) Any other comments relating to the game itself?
Just that it played out to be a great game, and we were all really anxious at the end. (as you saw
) If something happens like that again call me and let me know who's who so I can post it and we can all get a decent ammount of sleep.
Hmm... 6=8; 7=9. I think I'd rather have it still be at 7, because that gives me more time since I'm usually busy during the day on weekends. But 6 would seem to help more people, so either would be fine.
2) Aside from a few mistakes, were there any problems you saw in this game?
Nope.
3) Was the game fairly balanced? Was it unfair to one side? If so... which?
I don't think so, it came really close at the end, which means, in my opinion, that both sides were pretty even.
4) Any other comments relating to the game itself?
Just that it played out to be a great game, and we were all really anxious at the end. (as you saw
) If something happens like that again call me and let me know who's who so I can post it and we can all get a decent ammount of sleep.
Tue Nov 16, 2004 11:05 pm
1) Would you rather executions take place at 6 or 7 pm?
6 PM, please. Otherwise I have to wait until I get up in the morning (different time zone) to see who has been killed. And it's no fun to find you have to read five pages of posts fifteen minutes after you wake up.
2) Aside from a few mistakes, were there any problems you saw in this game?
Well, I think the only thing I didn't think went smoothly was that I believe some of the people that were supposed to help the innocents helped the baddies. And there were a few power players as well, but no one can stop that.
3) Was the game fairly balanced? Was it unfair to one side? If so... which?
I think we need more baddies. I think next time, half the people should be baddies, and half the people should be innocent.
4) Any other comments relating to the game itself?
Nope.
6 PM, please. Otherwise I have to wait until I get up in the morning (different time zone) to see who has been killed. And it's no fun to find you have to read five pages of posts fifteen minutes after you wake up.
2) Aside from a few mistakes, were there any problems you saw in this game?
Well, I think the only thing I didn't think went smoothly was that I believe some of the people that were supposed to help the innocents helped the baddies. And there were a few power players as well, but no one can stop that.
3) Was the game fairly balanced? Was it unfair to one side? If so... which?
I think we need more baddies. I think next time, half the people should be baddies, and half the people should be innocent.
4) Any other comments relating to the game itself?
Nope.
Tue Nov 16, 2004 11:24 pm
Kugetsu wrote:This may have been answered, but is the sniper an innocent or baddie?
Sniper is an innocent
Tue Nov 16, 2004 11:45 pm
o_0 having half the people playing baddies is a BAD idea....thats way too unfair for anyone who gets an innocent role....
Tue Nov 16, 2004 11:48 pm
Correct. Ideally its 25%~33% baddies that would be the best.
50% would make it impossible.
33% tilts it to the difficult side.
25% makes it iffy.
I'll see what i can do with it. In the mean time... I'd say look for sign ups in a few days...
start of game by the weekend.
50% would make it impossible.
33% tilts it to the difficult side.
25% makes it iffy.
I'll see what i can do with it. In the mean time... I'd say look for sign ups in a few days...
start of game by the weekend.
Tue Nov 16, 2004 11:50 pm
1) Would you rather executions take place at 6 or 7 pm?
6pm would be easier for me.
2) Aside from a few mistakes, were there any problems you saw in this game?
Not really, for my first game, I had fun
3) Was the game fairly balanced? Was it unfair to one side? If so... which?
Quite balanced
4) Any other comments relating to the game itself?
No one finds it even moderately odd that I knew Cae was the axe murderer and was working with her? Even when I was an innocent? *smiles at White_Wolf*
---
hyperflutterby, Thank you for protecting me from the Mafia!
6pm would be easier for me.
2) Aside from a few mistakes, were there any problems you saw in this game?
Not really, for my first game, I had fun
3) Was the game fairly balanced? Was it unfair to one side? If so... which?
Quite balanced
4) Any other comments relating to the game itself?
No one finds it even moderately odd that I knew Cae was the axe murderer and was working with her? Even when I was an innocent? *smiles at White_Wolf*
---
hyperflutterby, Thank you for protecting me from the Mafia!
Wed Nov 17, 2004 12:13 am
Xil wrote:4) Any other comments relating to the game itself?
No one finds it even moderately odd that I knew Cae was the axe murderer and was working with her? Even when I was an innocent? *smiles at White_Wolf*
*snicker*
I don't know that they've figured that out yet Dan
Too bad alex had to go and kill me.. That plan might've worked xD
Wed Nov 17, 2004 2:17 am
Um actually, yeah that's pretty confusing... Are you going to explain it or just let us wonder forever?