Discuss music in any form from rock bands to Britney Spears' latest VMA performance. It's all good!
Topic locked

Sun May 08, 2005 9:00 am

Er, I'm pretty sure just "punk" is a type of music, a la Sex Pistols, Ramones, Siouxsie and The Banshees, etc. Isn't "punk ROCK" just Good Charlotte and co?

Sun May 08, 2005 9:14 am

Meh, punk is a genre as far as I can see. As soon as anyone mentions "punk" I think of the band Minor Threat. :D

Sun May 08, 2005 11:30 am

.:Chronically Depressed:. wrote:
01000011 wrote:Anything "punk."

What's that supposed to mean? "Punk" as you put it is not a type of music.
Punk ROCK is. And then you're probably grouping Rock, Metal, Punk Rock, and many others...

What rubbish is this?
Punk is a genre. Like Jo said, Sex Pistols, Ramones, The Clash etc.

Punk Rock would be a mixture of Punk and rock.

Honestly, the useless numpties about...

Anyway, Good Charlotte et al are either PUNK RAWK or pop-punk or "punk". Putting it in the air quotes means they think they're ounk but you disagree.

Sun May 08, 2005 12:55 pm

Yoshi wrote:
Raven Poet wrote:Justin Timberlake. Urgh. >.<

You gotta admit, he sings like a girl. :P And he even does so in that Senorita song.


Does he ever! I laughed out loud when I saw the music video for 'Signs'. :lol:

Sun May 08, 2005 5:43 pm

Ashlip Syncson, aka Ashlee Simpson. PM me for a link to a petition to stop her. :evil:

Sun May 08, 2005 5:55 pm

DM was on fire! wrote:Ashlip Syncson, aka Ashlee Simpson. PM me for a link to a petition to stop her. :evil:


...this comes from someone who likes Hilary

Sorry...>< that did sound a bit rude. Ashlee's voice is ok, but sometimes it sounds really bad, like the Orange Bowl thing.

-Avril Lavigne live. I like her and her voice is ok, but it's like when she's live, she doesn't even try.
-Most rap artists who try to 'sing.' *shudder*
-Hilary Duff- she really can't reach the high notes and her voice is very ordinary, at best.
Last edited by Hil on Sun May 08, 2005 6:11 pm, edited 1 time in total.

Sun May 08, 2005 6:02 pm

Raven Poet wrote:
Yoshi wrote:
Raven Poet wrote:Justin Timberlake. Urgh. >.<

You gotta admit, he sings like a girl. :P And he even does so in that Senorita song.


What's wrong with that?

Sun May 08, 2005 6:13 pm

Mermaid Hil wrote:...this comes from someone who likes Hilary


Hey, we all like our different types I music. I just feel that Ashlee Simpson is teh ebil. (But she's still pretty.)

Sun May 08, 2005 7:30 pm

Igg wrote:
.:Chronically Depressed:. wrote:
01000011 wrote:Anything "punk."

What's that supposed to mean? "Punk" as you put it is not a type of music.
Punk ROCK is. And then you're probably grouping Rock, Metal, Punk Rock, and many others...

What rubbish is this?
Punk is a genre. Like Jo said, Sex Pistols, Ramones, The Clash etc.

Punk Rock would be a mixture of Punk and rock.

Honestly, the useless numpties about...

Anyway, Good Charlotte et al are either PUNK RAWK or pop-punk or "punk". Putting it in the air quotes means they think they're ounk but you disagree.


*snuggles Iggy* Right you are. However Good Charlotte should be shoved far, far away from anything including the word punk. :P *sigh* Remember when I was one of the misguided ones? XD

Sun May 08, 2005 9:08 pm

-Avril Lavigne (Meh. She can't sing. I suppose I like her so much because her songs are nice. And angsty. Can't go wrong with angsty.)

-Green Day (I'll be the first to admit some of their songs are okay, and dare I say it- good. But it's because of the music in the background that I like. I dislike the singing. Somewhat much.)

-Aaron Carter (Absolutely no talent).

-Nick Carter (Suckiness runs in the family.)

And the ultimate evils.

-Rascal Flatts (They bring absolute shame to country music. Absolute shame.)

-And the bigger of the two evils, HILARY DUFF. (She CANNOT sing a SINGLE NOTE right. She shouldn't even be famous at all. She can BARELY act, and as mentioned before, she CANNOT sing. Just TALKING about her CRAPPINESS makes me angry. But that's sorta because I have some anger issues. Oh well. She still ticks me off.)

Sun May 08, 2005 9:12 pm

Kyra wrote:
Igg wrote:
.:Chronically Depressed:. wrote:
01000011 wrote:Anything "punk."

What's that supposed to mean? "Punk" as you put it is not a type of music.
Punk ROCK is. And then you're probably grouping Rock, Metal, Punk Rock, and many others...

What rubbish is this?
Punk is a genre. Like Jo said, Sex Pistols, Ramones, The Clash etc.

Punk Rock would be a mixture of Punk and rock.

Honestly, the useless numpties about...

Anyway, Good Charlotte et al are either PUNK RAWK or pop-punk or "punk". Putting it in the air quotes means they think they're ounk but you disagree.


*snuggles Iggy* Right you are. However Good Charlotte should be shoved far, far away from anything including the word punk. :P *sigh* Remember when I was one of the misguided ones? XD

I do
*pat pat*
*pat pat*

pop-punk as I know it is a world away from punk, and doesn't include any real punk nuances.

Mon May 09, 2005 12:02 pm

Dawn2 wrote:-And the bigger of the two evils, HILARY DUFF. (She CANNOT sing a SINGLE NOTE right. She shouldn't even be famous at all. She can BARELY act, and as mentioned before, she CANNOT sing. Just TALKING about her CRAPPINESS makes me angry. But that's sorta because I have some anger issues. Oh well. She still ticks me off.)


Just another prime example of Disney Insta-Star (no talent required.)

Mon May 09, 2005 6:30 pm

lucie silvas, delta goodrem.

Mon May 09, 2005 9:57 pm

DM was on fire! wrote:Ashlip Syncson, aka Ashlee Simpson. PM me for a link to a petition to stop her. :evil:


A petition to stop a singer? That's a new one.

Mon May 09, 2005 10:19 pm

halfbakedbliss wrote:
Dawn2 wrote:-And the bigger of the two evils, HILARY DUFF. (She CANNOT sing a SINGLE NOTE right. She shouldn't even be famous at all. She can BARELY act, and as mentioned before, she CANNOT sing. Just TALKING about her CRAPPINESS makes me angry. But that's sorta because I have some anger issues. Oh well. She still ticks me off.)


Just another prime example of Disney Insta-Star (no talent required.)


I couldn't agree more. They seem to be turning almost every actor into a singer (Raven, Christy Carlson Romano, Lindsay Lohan, Hilary Duff, to name a few).
Topic locked