Goodness, that's tough.
I've already got my Christmas Meowclops, Avabot, Eustabee, Froiler, and Halloween Blooky (the last not currently on a pet -- I want to make
lots of Halloween pets, so it'll probably go with one of them).
Off-topic: I actually want to do a couple accounts of Halloweenish pets (not quite all of them painted 'Halloween') -- one for really spooky pets (like the evil-looking Halloween and Darigan Zafaras) and one for pets that are more like kids dressed up for trick-or-treating (like the Halloween Moehog and Shoyru). But of course, I'd like to have at least 5 pets on each of those accounts, and Neopets hasn't declared me Borovan yet.
Um,
Fire Angelpuss (to be the petpet of a Christmas Zafara),
Plushie GX-4 Oscillabot (this one tickles my funnybone for some reason),
edit -- almost forgot the sensational new
Mutant Fir! -- Halloween Whoot (probably for a Halloween Zafara), maybe a Halloween Flizzardo; Pirate Meowclops, Sketchy Meowclops, Slorgclops; Island Spyder, Robot Spyder, maybe a Pink Spyder (if I could figure out the right pet for it); Fire Feepit, and I was surprised to find I like the Faerie Feepit; Gallions look good in so many colors.
I want to be able to paint my Ganuthor Black, or maybe Fire, but those colors don't exist for it yet.
Before the revamp I wanted them to create a Fire Abominable Snowball, but now I don't care.
Nearly every Maraquan petpet. (The Cobrall is not at all bad, but the all others so far are
wonderful.)
The new Brown Kookith puts me in mind of a Whitman's Sampler chocolate (maybe I'd put it with one of my trick-or-treaters). (Oh, and then maybe a Pink Sludgy for bubble gum could go on another!)


If I had to choose just one, it'd be one of those three, I guess.
Choosing right this moment? Hmmm.
Ah, heck -- the Mutant Fir. It's irresistable.
Desires subject to change depending on whim, what pet it's for, and what new goodies come out (especially next month for guess-what-holiday).